Deadlock in a 50/50 North Carolina LLC

A 50/50 split can feel like the fairest way to start a business. But when two owners disagree, equal voting power can leave the company unable to make its next move. A stalled budget, an unsigned contract, or a rejected sale proposal can quickly threaten the business both members worked to build.

North Carolina law provides potential remedies, but it does not promise a quick buyout or an automatic solution. And a "shotgun" clause that looks balanced on paper may give a decisive advantage to the member with more cash.

Here is what North Carolina's LLC statute actually says, what a carefully drafted operating agreement should address, and how to evaluate a buy-sell mechanism before it turns a business dispute into a financial contest.

1. What North Carolina law provides, and what it doesn't

North Carolina's Limited Liability Company Act, Chapter 57D, gives a member a potential path to ask a court to dissolve an LLC. Under N.C. Gen. Stat. § 57D-6-02(2), a court may dissolve an LLC in a proceeding brought by a member if it is established either that:

  • it is not practicable to conduct the LLC's business in conformance with its operating agreement and Chapter 57D (clause (i)); or

  • liquidation is necessary to protect the member's rights and interests (clause (ii)).

Deadlock can be relevant, but simply being unable to agree does not automatically dissolve the company. The court looks at the business's circumstances, its governing documents, and whether the impasse prevents the company from carrying out its purpose.

In James H.Q. Davis Trust v. JHD Properties, LLC, No. 32PA24 (N.C. Jan. 31, 2025), the North Carolina Supreme Court affirmed dissolution of two family LLCs whose only two managers had reached a persistent impasse and whose operating agreements contained no mechanism to break it. The analysis was fact-intensive rather than a checklist: the Court considered whether the managers could work together, whether they were deadlocked, and whether the agreements offered a solution, and it relied on the absence of evidence that the companies' current activity was fulfilling their stated purpose. A company can be technically functional and still be operating in what the Court described as a residual, inertial status quo.

That last point matters for a deadlocked business that is still operating. Impasse alone is not the whole inquiry; whether the company can still accomplish what it was formed to do carries real weight.

Two statutory details that change the picture.

First, the buyout alternative is narrower than owners expect. Under § 57D-6-03(d), a court will not order dissolution if, after its decision, the LLC or one or more other members elect to purchase the complaining member's interest at fair value. Read that carefully: the election belongs to the company and the other members, not to the member who filed suit. You cannot use this provision to force your co-owner to buy you out. It is your co-owner's option to avoid dissolution.

Second, that alternative applies only to cases brought under clause (ii). By its text, § 57D-6-03(d) does not create the same purchase option in a case based solely on impracticability under clause (i), which is the clause JHD Properties was decided under, and the clause most likely to fit a pure management deadlock. In other words, the ground most likely to succeed in a deadlock case is the ground that carries no buyout off-ramp.

The statute also lets a court, in a dissolution proceeding, issue injunctions, appoint a receiver, or take other action needed to manage the LLC and its assets. But do not mistake that authority for a guaranteed, quick buyout.

Dissolution is not the only question, and often not the only claim. A member who is shut out of information, excluded from decisions, or harmed by a co-manager's conduct may have options beyond asking a court to end the company, including the information rights Chapter 57D provides to members and claims arising from a manager's duties. Those are separate analyses, and they sometimes matter more than dissolution does.

Can you simply leave instead? Generally not on your own terms. Chapter 57D does not give a member a general right to withdraw and be cashed out. A person who ceases to be a member typically becomes an economic interest owner entitled to the economic interest attributable to the ownership interest, but without management or voting rights, and the statute creates no automatic buyout, redemption, or fair-value payment simply because membership ends. Walking away usually means giving up control while keeping an economic stake you cannot easily monetize.

A practical note on procedure. A dissolution proceeding is brought against the LLC itself, and the other member generally cannot be joined unless you are seeking relief against that person for his or her own conduct. For an owner who imagines filing suit against a business partner, that reframes what the case actually looks like.

Litigation may also be slow, expensive, and uncertain. The parties may need to exchange records, obtain expert opinions, attend hearings, and contend with disputed facts before a court decides whether the statutory standard is met. Meanwhile, customers, employees, lenders, and vendors still need answers.

2. What your operating agreement should say before conflict starts

North Carolina gives operating agreements a broad role. Under § 57D-2-30, the operating agreement governs the LLC's internal affairs, and Chapter 57D applies only to the extent the agreement has not supplanted, varied, or nullified it. That makes the agreement the best place to set out a practical plan for decisions and disputes, before the members are locked in a standoff.

That freedom has limits worth knowing. Section 57D-2-30(b) protects a list of provisions from being contracted away, and a member's right to seek judicial dissolution under § 57D-6-02(2) is on that list unless the operating agreement provides an alternative remedy. The practical consequence is encouraging: you cannot simply delete the courthouse as an option, but you can give the members a workable private path: a defined buyout, an appraisal process, an agreed exit that addresses the problem before anyone files anything.

Without specific terms, statutory defaults govern. Under § 57D-3-20, members are generally managers unless the operating agreement provides otherwise; managers have equal management rights, and a majority of managers controls management decisions. In a two-manager LLC, that can mean no majority at all when the managers disagree. Some significant actions, such as amending the operating agreement, also require approval of all members under § 57D-3-03.

Consider a common scenario, purely by way of illustration. Two owners build a profitable services company on a handshake and a form operating agreement. Four years in, one wants to accept an acquisition offer, and the other wants to keep running the business. Neither has the votes. The agreement says nothing about tie-breaking, nothing about buyouts, and nothing about what counts as a major decision. Both owners are now stuck in a company that still has customers, payroll, and a lease, and no way to decide anything.

A 50/50 operating agreement should address:

  • Which decisions require unanimous approval. Reserve unanimity for clearly defined major actions: a sale, new debt above a stated amount, admission of a new member, rather than making every operational choice a two-person veto.

  • Who handles routine decisions. Consider naming a managing member or assigning authority by function, with limits, reporting requirements, and safeguards for major commitments.

  • How a tie gets resolved. A neutral adviser, independent director, or carefully limited casting vote may help with specified business questions. Define the decision-maker's scope and what happens if that person cannot serve.

  • A staged escalation process. Set deadlines for direct discussions, then mediation, and, if appropriate, confidential arbitration. State who selects the neutral, how costs are shared, and whether either member can seek urgent court relief.

  • A buyout process that works in real life. Specify triggering events, valuation procedures, payment timing, security, interest, and what happens if the buyer cannot close. Done well, this is also the "alternative remedy" that gives the agreement's dispute provisions real weight.

  • Transfer restrictions and continuity rules. Address permitted transfers, rights of first refusal, and what happens on death, disability, bankruptcy, or a proposed sale to an outsider.

Valuation deserves particular attention, and it comes down to three decisions. 

Method: a formula, an agreed appraiser, or a process using one appraiser per member and a third if the first two differ. 

Date: the valuation date, and how it relates to the triggering event. 

Adjustments: how debt and cash are treated, whether minority or marketability discounts apply, and how personal goodwill or owner-dependent revenue is handled.

A formula that once seemed sensible may become outdated as the business changes. Review the agreement when ownership, financing, or the company's business model shifts.

3. Why a "shotgun" clause can be unfair

Buy-sell clauses come in different forms, and labels are not always used consistently. In a classic shotgun mechanism, one member names a price for the other's interest. The recipient must choose either to sell at that price or buy the initiator's interest at the same price. In a Texas shoot-out auction, members submit competing bids, with the higher bid typically purchasing the other's interest.

There is a reason sophisticated parties use these clauses. They solve the specific problem a 50/50 structure creates: a member who will neither buy nor sell, and who can block every decision indefinitely. A shotgun provision forces that person to pick a side, and the requirement that the proposer be willing to sit on either side of the deal is a genuine discipline on an unreasonable price.

These are contract terms, and North Carolina courts generally enforce clear contract terms between commercial parties. We are not aware of a North Carolina appellate decision squarely addressing the enforceability of a shotgun buy-sell mechanism, so the practical question is less whether the clause will be honored than whether you want to live with what it produces.

Because neither approach guarantees fairness.

They work best when the owners have reasonably similar access to capital, comparable information about the business, and a genuine willingness either to buy or sell. If those conditions are missing, the mechanism can magnify existing power imbalances.

Deeper pockets can decide the outcome. A member with more personal wealth, easier access to financing, or the ability to secure a loan may be able to make an offer the other cannot match. The clause may force the less-liquid owner to sell, even though the price is nominally the same in both directions.

One member's contributions may not show up in the formula. A founder may have built key customer relationships, a reputation, or a personal brand that drives revenue. A formula based on book value, or one that fails to address owner-dependent goodwill, may not reflect what that work contributes.

Unequal access to information can distort pricing. If one member controls the books, knows about pending deals, or has a clearer view of liabilities and prospects, the other may be asked to name or accept a price without the same information.

Alternatives may include a fixed-price buyout with periodic updates and a defined adjustment process; an independent third-party appraisal; or a purchase at appraised value with installments, interest, and security for the seller. Another option is to require financial disclosure and a reasonable financing period before either party must make an election. Each approach needs precise terms: a fair valuation is not much help if the buyer has no workable payment schedule, or the seller has no protection for the unpaid balance.

Review the mechanism before the dispute escalates

If your North Carolina LLC is already deadlocked, preserve records, review the operating agreement, and avoid assuming that either member can force a quick sale. The outcome may depend on the agreement's language, the company's governance structure, and the nature and duration of the impasse.

If you are forming a company or revising its documents, build the decision and exit process around how the business actually operates, not just a standard template. Isaboke Law Firm® helps owners develop plain-English documents and business-first strategies. Our North Carolina business formation and structuring services and LLC operating agreement drafting and review can address governance before it becomes a crisis. If a dispute is already underway, our civil and business litigation services can help you assess options and protect the company's position.

This article is for educational purposes only and is not legal advice. North Carolina law and the terms of your operating agreement may affect your rights.

Previous
Previous

AI-Assisted Deliverables: What Your Business Can Safely Promise Clients About Ownership When Generative AI Helped Create the Work

Next
Next

The Personal Guaranty in Your Commercial Lease: What Can a North Carolina Landlord Collect From You Personally After Your Business Closes?